| Name of Play | # of Performances | Date Closed |
| The Fantasticks | 17,162 | 1-13-2002 |
1 | Phantom of the Opera | 7,767 + | Running |
2 | Cats | 7,485 | 9-10-2000 |
3 | Les Miserables | 6,680 | 5-18-2003 |
4 | A Chorus Line | 6,137 | 4-28-1990 |
5 | Oh, Calcutta! | 5,959 | 8-06-1989 |
6 | Beauty and the Beast | 5,093 + | Running |
7 | Rent | 4,315 + | Running |
8 | Chicago (1996 revival) | 4,093 | Running |
9 | Miss Saigon | 4,092 | 1-28-2001 |
10 | Lion King | 3,676 | Running |
11 | 42nd Street | 3,486 | 1-08-1989 |
12 | Grease | 3,388 | 4-13-1980 |